Logo

$95bn loss predicted to Australian economy if Div 296 passes: analysis

Analysis from one of the country’s biggest asset management firms has revealed a “deadweight loss” of $94.5 billion to the nation’s economy if the Division 296 tax gets over the line.

.

A discussion paper from Wilson Asset Management on the proposal by the current Labor government to tax unrealised gains within the superannuation system said this deadweight loss will impact all Australians, including those not currently in the proposed $3 million tax threshold.

“At first glance, such a measure may appear to offer a straightforward path to increased government revenue. However, beneath the surface lies a broken social contract, profound economic complexities, unintended consequences, and multiple potential pitfalls that demand rigorous scrutiny,” the paper said about the controversial super tax.

“The relationship between tax rates and revenue is not linear, and that excessive taxation can be self-defeating, shrinking the base it seeks to tap.”

The discussion paper, Critiquing the proposed taxation on unrealised gains in superannuation, said there were potentially 16.3 million Australians who would be affected by the proposed tax, and although industry super fund balances were generally lower than those held in SMSFs, they would still be captured by the proposed Division 296 tax.

“Whilst superannuation is critical to the Australian government, contributing nearly $50 billion in taxation revenue per annum, the challenge today is a policy vacuum of uncertainty. The current superannuation system, with the myriad of caps, thresholds, and transition-to-retirement strategies, can be overwhelming for any Australian,” it read.

“Although this paper focused on taxation of unrealised gains in superannuation, simplifying the broader rules around superannuation would not only reduce the administrative burden, it would also improve transparency and accessibility. A more streamlined system would empower individuals to make informed decisions about their retirement savings.”

In relation to SMSFs in particular, the paper said the proposed tax would likely see SMSFs abandon the structure or significantly reduce assets to below $3 million by June 2026.

“There is a risk that more people will be pushed onto a government-reliant pension,” it said.

“Treasury modelling already predicts the $59 billion spent on the aged pension today declines as a percentage of GDP in the future due in most part to the expansion of the SMSF sector. The proposed tax on unrealised gains in superannuation will reverse the benefits embedded in Treasury forecasts as reliance on the government pension increases.”

The analysis calculated that the deadweight loss from taxing unrealised gains in super is $94.5 billion in lost economic efficiency from imposing a higher tax on superannuation.

It continued that a tax perceived as eroding accumulated wealth, such as the proposed taxing of unrealised gains in super balances over $3 million, may lead to reduced savings, increased consumption, or a shift towards less taxed investment options.

“Conversely, tax policies seen as promoting wealth accumulation can encourage savings and investment. The proposed policy is the former having a direct impact on reducing savings and encouraging people to alternative tax structures.”

“However, policy objectives are now shifting towards revenue generation. This reduces government credibility and alerted behaviours. This lack of trust leads savers to save less, undermining the system’s goals.”

The paper said taxing unrealised gains disrupts this incentive structure, potentially leading to reduced savings in the overall pool of retirement savings, distorted investment decisions and higher portfolio turnover, increased transaction costs, and potentially lower overall returns for superannuation account holders.

It could also lead to a shift to assets that are less likely to generate substantial unrealised gains, which could subsequently reduce the overall productivity of capital allocation within the Australian economy.

“If the tax significantly discourages investment and economic activity, it could lead to slower economic growth and lower overall capital gains across the economy, including within superannuation,” the paper said.

“This would further diminish the revenue potential from taxing unrealised gains. There are also intergenerational impacts and taxing unrealised gains may force premature liquidation of assets intended for inheritance. This could shift the timing and amount of wealth transferred between generations, reducing inheritances and then increasing dependence on the state for future generations.”

The paper concluded that instead of pursuing “this economically unsound and practically challenging tax”, policymakers should reconsider their approach and explore alternative strategies for revenue generation.

“A comprehensive review of the potential negative consequences, careful consideration of global lessons learned, and meaningful consultation is essential before proceeding with any policy that could undermine the retirement security of Australians and damage the nation's economic future.”

 

 

 

Keeli Cambourne
April 29 2025
smsfadviser.com

Want to know more?

Do you have a question about something you've read in this article? Need more information? Want to book an appointment? Simply let us know below and we'll get back to you ASAP.

General Advice Disclaimer

The advice provided on this website is general advice only. It has been prepared without taking into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Before acting on this advice you should consider the appropriateness of the advice, having regard to your own objectives, financial situation and needs. If any products are detailed on this website, you should obtain a Product Disclosure Statement relating to the products and consider its contents before making any decisions.

Barnett Financial Planning Pty Ltd disclaim all and any guarantees, undertakings and warranties, expressed or implied, and shall not be liable for any loss or damage whatsoever (including human or computer error, negligent or otherwise, or incidental or consequential loss or damage) arising out of or in connection with any use or reliance on the information or advice on this site. The user must accept sole responsibility associated with the use of the material on this site, irrespective of the purpose for which such use or results are applied. The information on this website is no substitute for financial advice.

Privacy Policy

About this policy

METRISCOPE Financial Pty Ltd (METRISCOPE) recognises the importance of privacy and is committed to protecting the privacy of individuals when handling their personal information.

This Privacy Policy explains in an open and transparent manner how METRISCOPE will collect, hold, use, disclose, protect and otherwise handle your personal information in accordance with the Australian Privacy Principles contained in the Privacy Act 1988 (Cth).

When you provide METRISCOPE with personal information you consent to its use, disclosure and handling of your personal information in accordance with this Privacy Policy as amended from time to time.

Your Personal Information METRISCOPE collects and holds

METRISCOPE will collect and hold your personal information for the purposes of providing our investment services and products to you.

The kinds of personal information that we may collect and hold include your name, date of birth, tax file number, email address, home address, phone number and bank account details.

Where you do not provide us with all or some of your personal information that we request then we may not be able to provide you with our services.

Personal information collected and held

METRISCOPE collects your personal information directly from you and through our intermediaries when you complete fund application forms. METRISCOPE may also collect data from its registry services.

Other ways METRISCOPE may collect your personal information includes in person or by telephone, letter, facsimile or email.

METRISCOPE may hold personal information collected in both physical and electronic storage facilities including paper-based files and computer databases.

How METRISCOPE uses and discloses personal information

METRISCOPE may use and disclose personal information collected and stored to enable us to provide the financial services and products to you and for other related legal purposes.

For example, we may use and/or disclose your personal information to:

  1. verify your identity;
  2. administer your accounts, investments and the services we provide to you;
  3. comply with laws, regulations, rules, directions or requests from METRISCOPE’s regulatory bodies and/or other government agencies;
  4. comply with METRISCOPE’s own internal policies and procedures.

Where it is legal and necessary to do so, METRISCOPE may disclose your personal information for the purposes described above to our suppliers, contractors, professional advisers, government agencies and regulators or parties involved in the management of your account.

These third parties may be in other countries where laws in relation to the processing of personal information are not consistent with the Australian Privacy Principles or the Privacy Act.

While METRISCOPE may take steps to try and ensure that these third parties do not breach the Australian Privacy Principles in relation to your personal information, the overseas recipient may breach the Privacy Act and/or the Privacy Principles and this may be due to that countries own laws.

By providing us with your personal information you accept that we may make disclosures to overseas recipients on this basis.

METRISCOPE will protect your personal information

METRISCOPE will take all reasonable steps to protect your personal information it holds from misuse, interference and loss, and from unauthorised access, modification or disclosure using both physical and electronic security measures.

By providing us with your personal information over the Internet you accept that such information will be transmitted at your own risk as the security of such information cannot be guaranteed.

METRISCOPE will not retain your personal information, unless required by law, if it is no longer needed for any purpose for which we may lawfully use or disclose it.

Access, correction and complaints regarding your personal information

You may request METRISCOPE to provide you with access to any of your personal information held by us. You should promptly notify METRISCOPE if you become aware that any of your personal information held is inaccurate, out-of-date, incomplete, irrelevant or misleading.

If you have any concerns about whether METRISCOPE has complied with this Privacy Policy or the Privacy Act you can raise your concerns with our Compliance Manager.

You can contact our Compliance Manager via email, fax, telephone or by post on the details set out below. Our Compliance Manager will investigate your complaint and advise you of the outcome.

If you are not satisfied with our response you can complain to the Office of the Australian Information Commissioner.

You can contact our Compliance Manager using the contact details below:

Compliance Manager

compliance@metriscope.com.au

Phone: 02 9659 3955

Fax: 02 9659 4912

Address: PO Box 2036, Castle Hill NSW 1765

We will acknowledge receipt of a complaint within 1 business day, however, where this is not possible, acknowledgement will be made as soon as practicable. We will then investigate the complaint and respond to you within 30 days. Some complex matters may require an extension to thoroughly investigate the complaint and bring it to resolution. If additional time is required, we will advise you in writing.

If you are not fully satisfied with our response, you can contact an external body. In cases of privacy related complaints, this is generally the Office of the Australian Information Commissioner (OAIC).

The contact details for OAIC are:

Mail GPO box 5218 Sydney NSW 2001

Phone 1300 363 992

Email enquiries@oaic.gov.au

Online www.oaic.gov.au

You may also direct privacy complaints related to financial advice to the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA). The contact details for AFCA are:

Mail GPO Box 3, Melbourne, VIC 3001

Phone 1800 931 678 (free call)

Email info@afca.org.au

Online www.afca.org.au

Privacy Policy updates

We may update this Privacy Policy from time to time to take into account changes in our practices for the handling of personal information by publishing an amended Privacy Policy. You should regularly review the most recent version of this Privacy Policy.

Complaints Policy

Complaints Resolution

If you have a complaint we would like you to tell us so that we can address the matter. We are committed to the efficient and fair resolution of complaints.

How you can lodge a complaint

If you wish to make a complaint, please contact our Compliance Manager on the information below:

Compliance Manager
compliance@metriscope.com.au
Phone: 02 9659 3955
Fax: 02 9659 4912
Address: PO Box 2036, Castle Hill NSW 1765

Our complaint process is free of charge to you. Your complaint does not need to be in writing. If you require any assistance to lodge your complaint, please let us know. You may also choose to authorise a representative to make a complaint on your behalf.

We are bound by the Privacy Act, and we manage and protect your personal information in accordance with the Australian Privacy Principles.

How we will deal with your complaint

We will respond to your complaint in a timely and flexible manner. Our goal is to ensure the earliest possible resolution and we will try to resolve your complaint wherever possible at the first point of contact. Where your complaint is urgent it will be prioritised.

We will ensure you have the opportunity to explain your complaint. To this end we ask that where possible, that you provide the following information about your complaint:

We will address your complaint fairly and consistently, treating each complaint in an un-biased manner, and ensuring all allegations are investigated thoroughly. We will inform the financial adviser or mortgage broker involved about your complaint and ask them to respond to us.

Once your complaint is resolved any agreed outcomes will be implemented in a timely manner.

How and when we will communicate with you about your complaint

We will acknowledge the receipt of your complaint within 1 business day verbally or in writing.

Where this is not possible, acknowledgement will be made as soon as possible.

We will investigate your complaint promptly and respond to you within 30 calendar days. Our response will include:

If we are able to resolve the complaint to your complete satisfaction within 5 business days, we may not provide a written response unless you request a response in writing.

Some complex matters may require additional time to thoroughly investigate the complaint and bring it to a resolution. Where additional time is required, we will advise you in writing within 30 calendar days of receiving the complaint. We will explain the reasons for the delay.

We will communicate openly throughout the process.

If you are not satisfied with the resolution of your complaint, you can lodge a complaint with the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA).

Your right to lodge a complaint with AFCA

If an issue has not been resolved to your satisfaction, you can lodge a complaint with AFCA. AFCA provides fair and independent complaint resolution that is free to consumers. The contact details for AFCA are:

Mail GPO Box 3, Melbourne VIC 3001
Phone 1800 931 678 (free of charge)
Email info@afca.org.au
Online www.afca.org.au

About this Policy

We may amend or update our Complaints Policy as required by law or as our business processes changes.